Travel insurance comparison sites are usually not cheaper than buying direct: for the same plan, they charge what the insurer charges⁠[3]⁠[4]. As of November 2026, Select Your Cover checked the state rules behind that, and they are less uniform than one marketplace's line that "It is illegal to discount travel insurance policies in any way"⁠[3]. Washington and Florida allow some rebates or discounts under set conditions⁠[5]⁠[6], and California's code refers to commission rebates authorized by Proposition 103⁠[7].

The reason prices match is rate filing. In West Virginia, travel insurance rates must be filed with the commissioner before they are used⁠[1]. The catch is that West Virginia and Florida both allow plans built for a particular sales channel⁠[1]⁠[13].

Picture the common case. You have a family trip booked and you are comparing plans on a broker site for the first time. The prices look identical to what the insurers show on their own sites, so you wonder what the site is for, who pays it, and whether it will get in the way if you ever file a claim.

Does the same plan cost less if you buy it from the insurer?

For the same plan, usually not. In West Virginia, for example, all travel insurance policies, endorsements and rates charged in the state "shall be filed with the commissioner before being used"⁠[1]. In states that require filing, the seller charges the filed rate for that plan.

The sites say the same. Squaremouth's help page says "travel insurance prices are regulated by state law, so the rate you see on Squaremouth is the same you would pay if buying directly from the provider"⁠[3]. Seven Corners, a travel insurance company that sells direct, makes the same point from the other side: "you aren't likely to save money because the aggregator's price is the same as the insurance company's"⁠[4].

So the reason to use a comparison site is the comparison, not a lower price on any one plan. Seven Corners notes that on an insurer's website "you won't find the same wide variety of plans as you would on a comparison website"⁠[4].

Can a travel insurance comparison site give you a discount?

It depends on your state, and on whether the discount is in a filing or a rebate schedule. Squaremouth's help page says "It is illegal to discount travel insurance policies in any way"⁠[3]. State law is less uniform than that line suggests.

Washington bars insurers and producers from giving any "rebate, discount, abatement, or reduction of premium" as an inducement, but that ban starts with "Except to the extent provided for in an applicable filing with the commissioner then in effect"⁠[5]. Florida allows an agent to rebate part of a commission when the rebate is "in accordance with a rebating schedule filed by the agent with the insurer" and is available to all insureds in the same actuarial class⁠[6]. California's claims-referral anti-kickback section says it does not apply to "the rebating of commissions by insurance agents or brokers, as authorized by Proposition 103"⁠[7].

What state rules say about discounts and channel pricing. Source: the state statutes and filing instructions cited⁠[1]⁠[2]⁠[5]⁠[6]⁠[7]⁠[13]. Checked by Select Your Cover on Nov 17, 2026.
StateWhat the rule saysWhat it means for you
WashingtonNo rebate or premium reduction, except as an applicable filing providesA discount has to be in the insurer's filing
FloridaAn agent may rebate commission on a schedule filed with the insurer; travel plans can be built for identified distribution channelsAsk a licensed agent for their rebate schedule; the same policy must get the same percentage for everyone
CaliforniaThe claims-referral anti-kickback section does not apply to commission rebates authorized by Proposition 103This anti-kickback section does not block a Prop 103 commission rebate, so ask the agent
West VirginiaRates filed before use; eligibility and underwriting standards can be built for identified distribution channelsA plan sold in one channel can have its own eligibility rules
NevadaInsurers must justify either one rate for all channels or separate channel ratesOnline and membership prices can differ, if justified

Florida's rule has limits. Rebates "shall not be given to an insured with respect to a policy purchased from an insurer that prohibits its agents from rebating commissions"⁠[6], and the schedule must be displayed in the agent's place of business, with a copy available to insureds on request at no charge⁠[6]. It must be "uniformly applied," so everyone buying the same policy for the same amount gets the same percentage, and the agent cannot use your age, place of residence or occupation to decide the rebate⁠[6].

Is the plan on a comparison site the same plan the insurer sells direct?

Usually, but check the plan name and form, not just the brand. West Virginia's law says eligibility and underwriting standards "may be developed and provided based on travel protection plans designed for individual or identified marketing or distribution channels"⁠[1], and Florida uses almost the same words for travel insurance programs⁠[13]. Nevada tells insurers that "If channels are rated separately, demonstrate rates vary appropriately based on expected losses and expenses"⁠[2].

In plain terms, West Virginia's law allows plans with their own eligibility and underwriting rules for a sales channel, and Nevada's filing instructions let insurers rate channels separately if justified by expected losses and expenses. Squaremouth's help page says "a travel insurance plan is exactly the same regardless of where it is sold"⁠[3]. That holds when it is the same filed plan. If the name or the form number on the two quotes differs, you are comparing two plans.

What people get wrong about comparison sites

"The site marks up the price to make its money." In states that require filing, the seller charges the filed rate⁠[1], and Squaremouth says its rate is the same as buying direct⁠[3]. Squaremouth's terms say its parent company "may share commissions or referral fees with business partners"⁠[8], and its affiliate page tells partners "Every time someone buys a travel insurance policy through that link, you earn commission"⁠[9].

"Discounts on travel insurance are always illegal." That is how one site's help page puts it⁠[3]. Washington, Florida and California each write the rule differently, as the table shows⁠[5]⁠[6]⁠[7].

"Buying through a broker means the broker handles my claim." Squaremouth's help page says "you'll work directly with the travel insurance provider listed on your policy to settle it"⁠[3].

Who pays a comparison site, and can you ask how much?

Not every site spells it out, but Squaremouth's pages point to a licensed agency model. Its terms say its parent and subsidiaries "are licensed as insurance brokers or agents in various U.S. states"⁠[8], and its site footer lists "SPG Insurance Solutions License No. 0L09546" for California⁠[12]. Squaremouth also says "Our agents do not work on commission"⁠[3], which is about its customer service agents.

In New York, you can ask for the numbers. Unless an exemption in the rules applies, a state regulation requires a producer selling an insurance contract to disclose "whether the insurance producer will receive compensation from the selling insurer or other third party"⁠[10]. It must also tell you "that the compensation paid to the insurance producer may vary depending on a number of factors, including (if applicable) the insurance contract and the insurer that the purchaser selects"⁠[10], and that you can request details⁠[10]. If you ask before the policy is issued, the producer must put the details in writing⁠[10].

Select Your Cover is paid by some of these marketplaces too. See who pays us.

Illustration of a couple planning a trip at a kitchen table with passports, a calendar and a laptop
Quote the same plan on the comparison site and on the insurer's own site, then compare the plan name and form.

Who handles your claim if you buy through a comparison site?

The insurer on your policy does. Squaremouth's help page says you will work directly with the provider listed on your policy, and that your policy documents come with instructions on how to file a claim⁠[3]. Squaremouth adds that "Every policy on Squaremouth is backed by our Zero Complaint Guarantee, a promise that we will advocate for you if your claim is unfairly denied"⁠[12].

So Squaremouth says it will step in if a claim is unfairly denied. The decision on the claim still rests with the insurer and the policy wording.

How do you check a comparison site's quote against the insurer's own?

Start with a rough range. An Alaska Division of Insurance guide, written during the COVID-19 outbreak, says "Travel insurance usually costs between 4-10% of a trip's price" and gives an example: "for a trip that costs $5,000, travel insurance could range from $200 to $500 depending on the coverage"⁠[11].

Redo it with your trip:

  1. Add up your prepaid, nonrefundable trip cost.
  2. Multiply it by 0.04 and by 0.10. That gives the rough range Alaska describes.
  3. Quote one plan on a comparison site. Then quote the same plan, for the same traveler ages, state and trip dates, on the insurer's own site.
  4. If the price matches, you have seen what Squaremouth and Seven Corners describe⁠[3]⁠[4]. If it differs, compare the plan names and form numbers first, since a plan built for one sales channel can have its own eligibility rules⁠[1]⁠[13].

What should you check before you buy on a comparison site?

  1. Match the plan, not the brand. Same plan name, same form, same state of residence⁠[1].
  2. Ask about discounts only where the law allows them. Florida rebates must follow the agent's filed schedule⁠[6].
  3. Know who pays the claim. It is the insurer listed on the policy⁠[3].
  4. In New York, ask what the seller earns on the plan you picked and on the alternatives it showed you⁠[10].

For how plans differ on cancellation, medical and delay benefits, see our travel insurance comparison, the travel insurance hub and is travel insurance worth it.

We earn commissions from some companies on this page, and that can affect the order they appear in. It never changes our scores.

This page explains how travel insurance sales are typically regulated. Your state's rules and your policy wording decide your price and your claim. It is not insurance advice.

Common questions

Is it cheaper to buy travel insurance directly from the insurer?

Usually not for the same plan. Squaremouth's help page says travel insurance prices are regulated by law, so there is no financial benefit to buying directly from a provider. Seven Corners, a travel insurance company that sells direct, says you aren't likely to save money because the aggregator's price is the same as the insurance company's.

Can a travel insurance comparison site give me a discount?

It depends on the state. Washington bans rebates and premium reductions except to the extent an applicable filing provides for them. Florida lets a licensed agent rebate part of a commission if it follows a schedule filed with the insurer. California's code refers to commission rebating by agents and brokers as authorized by Proposition 103.

Who pays travel insurance comparison sites?

Not every site publishes this. Squaremouth's terms say its parent company is licensed as an insurance broker or agent in various states and may share commissions or referral fees with business partners, and its affiliate page pays partners commission on each policy sold through their link. In New York, unless an exemption applies, a producer must tell you whether the insurer pays them.

Who handles my claim if I buy through a comparison site?

The insurer does. Squaremouth's help page says you will work directly with the travel insurance provider listed on your policy to settle a claim. Squaremouth, for its own sales, also says it will advocate for you if a claim is unfairly denied, under what it calls its Zero Complaint Guarantee.

How much does travel insurance cost?

An Alaska Division of Insurance guide written during the COVID-19 outbreak says travel insurance usually costs between 4-10% of a trip's price. On a $5,000 trip, that range is $200 to $500 depending on the coverage. It is a rough guide, so use it to sanity-check the quotes a comparison site shows you.

Sources

  1. [1] West Virginia Code 33-62-6, Travel insurance forms and rates · accessed 2026-11-17
  2. [2] Nevada Division of Insurance: Travel insurance rate filing instructions · accessed 2026-11-17
  3. [3] Squaremouth help center: Does it cost me any more to purchase from Squaremouth? · accessed 2026-11-17
  4. [4] Seven Corners: Travel insurance companies vs. travel comparison sites · accessed 2026-11-17
  5. [5] Revised Code of Washington 48.30.140, Rebating, other inducements · accessed 2026-11-17
  6. [6] Florida Statutes 626.572, Rebating; when allowed · accessed 2026-11-17
  7. [7] California Insurance Code section 750 (via California.Public.Law) · accessed 2026-11-17
  8. [8] Squaremouth: Terms and conditions · accessed 2026-11-17
  9. [9] Squaremouth: Travel insurance affiliate program · accessed 2026-11-17
  10. [10] New York 11 NYCRR 30.3, Disclosure of producer compensation (via Cornell LII) · accessed 2026-11-17
  11. [11] Alaska Division of Insurance: Travel insurance consumer guide · accessed 2026-11-17
  12. [12] Squaremouth: About Squaremouth · accessed 2026-11-17
  13. [13] Florida Statutes 647.07, Travel insurance policy · accessed 2026-11-17

All travel insurance guides →

More guides

All guides →

Compare other cover